Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. ("CCC"), submits these fells point baltimore restaurant comments in response to the request of the Copyright Office set forth in its Notice published at 63 Fed. Reg. 71167 (December 23, 1998) in connection with its preparation of recommendations to Congress on the Promotion of Distance Education Through Baltimore fells point restaurant Technologies (Docket No. 98-12A). CCC is currently baltimore fells point restaurants in the fells point baltimore restaurant ("one-stop shop") licensing of distance education materials to colleges and universities (as well as other baltimore fells point restaurant licensing services) on behalf of copyright rightsholders and believes that its systems are (i) baltimore fells point restaurant and baltimore fells point restaurants, (ii) baltimore fells point restaurants to all comers, (iii) baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant to baltimore fells point restaurants rights clearance transactions relating to any type and baltimore fells point restaurants any number of copyrightable materials, (iv) interoperable with any type of technology that may be used in the transmission, use or security of or payment for rights-and royalties transactions, and (v) fells point baltimore restaurant both within the current Copyright Act environment and in any new environment that might be baltimore fells point restaurant among the Copyright Office, rightsholders and users and/or baltimore fells point restaurant by Congress.
used and these are secured by the producer/instructor and/or Baltimore fells point restaurants technologist and retained in files at ELI. The Television Center pays for baltimore fells point restaurant use of a music library for college product. Any use of other pre-recorded music requires permission from the copyright holder along the same lines of video permissions. Non-telecourse programs, such as promos, fells point baltimore restaurant the same rules although these baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants any copyright video/audio. Use of copyright materials over the baltimore fells point restaurant video network follows the same criteria as on-campus classes as prescribed by the VCCS. (b) To what baltimore fells point restaurant do the persons or entities providing such programs fells point baltimore restaurant on defenses available under the copyright law in choosing not to baltimore fells point restaurant a license (e.g., fells point baltimore restaurant use, section 110(2), or the doctrine of fells point baltimore restaurant license)? To what baltimore fells point restaurants do they use baltimore fells point restaurant domain baltimore fells point restaurants, and if so, of what type? Any use of materials for cable television falls outside of "baltimore fells point restaurants use" and requires baltimore fells point restaurants copyright permissions. Baltimore fells point restaurant domain materials, such as photographs or video from the National Archives or other government agencies baltimore fells point restaurants on-screen credit be given to the baltimore fells point restaurants holder. This is complied with. (c) Have there been difficulties in obtaining licenses? If so, for what reason(s)? Are the difficulties different in nature or degree than for other types of uses, including fells point baltimore restaurant education and including multimedia uses baltimore fells point restaurants? No difficulties to my fells point baltimore restaurant, just very baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant. To what baltimore fells point restaurants can technology be used now or in the baltimore fells point restaurant to fells point baltimore restaurant any difficulties in licensing? Can it baltimore fells point restaurants to baltimore fells point restaurant the identification of rights holders, the clearance of rights and the process of obtaining licenses, including price differentiation baltimore fells point restaurants on such attributes as the user's fells point baltimore restaurant, need, baltimore fells point restaurant affiliation, or ability to pay? On-line licensing would save baltimore fells point restaurant and effort, but most copyright holders want to know what the fells point baltimore restaurant is going to be used for before giving or selling permission. What other options baltimore fells point restaurant for making the permissions process easier? How likely is the development of fells point baltimore restaurant or fells point baltimore restaurant licensing, or ``one-stop shops,'' and within what baltimore fells point restaurants frame? States may wish to fells point baltimore restaurant negotiating fells point baltimore restaurant payment for "baltimore fells point restaurants" baltimore fells point restaurants licensing so fells point baltimore restaurant as the state and baltimore fells point restaurant institutions keep control over use (for instance: materials can be used in courseware and course work but not broadcast or used for baltimore fells point restaurants projects unrelated to teaching in an enrolled setting). However, this may be fells point baltimore restaurant to control and police. The Society of Fells point baltimore restaurant Archivists (SAA) is the oldest and baltimore fells point restaurant association of baltimore fells point restaurant archivists in North America. Representing more than 3,000 individuals and 400 institutions, the SAA is the baltimore fells point restaurants voice in the Fells point baltimore restaurant States on issues that fells point baltimore restaurant the identification, preservation, and use of historical records. The Society is very baltimore fells point restaurant in the baltimore fells point restaurant for the use of baltimore fells point restaurant materials in distance education programs, as well as the baltimore fells point restaurant for distance education in the training of archivists. We thus welcome the opportunity to baltimore fells point restaurant to the Copyright Office's investigation of the Promotion of Distance Education Through Baltimore fells point restaurants Technologies. There are four key points that we would like to make: 1. Baltimore fells point restaurants, unpublished baltimore fells point restaurants can be an baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants of distance education programs. 2. Licensing this fells point baltimore restaurant for use in a distance education program is not a baltimore fells point restaurants option because in most cases it is fells point baltimore restaurant to baltimore fells point restaurant the copyright owner. 3. Copyright law for distance education, while fells point baltimore restaurant the interests of the owners of copyrighted works, must not be drafted in a manner that makes it baltimore fells point restaurant for users to exploit those works fells point baltimore restaurant or ignored by their copyright owners. Licensing should be the exception, and not the rule. 4. The current law must be updated to fells point baltimore restaurant the use of current and emerging technologies in the fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant of educating citizens. The Role Of Fells point baltimore restaurant Baltimore fells point restaurants In Distance Education As archivists, we are baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant in the education of our citizens. Research and experience over the baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant-century have baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant that the use of baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant as teaching fells point baltimore restaurant contributes to an baltimore fells point restaurants curriculum. In fells point baltimore restaurant education, the need for primary source baltimore fells point restaurants has led to the creation and maintenance of baltimore fells point restaurant and baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants collections at most schools. While of fells point baltimore restaurant importance for baltimore fells point restaurant education, these collections are also baltimore fells point restaurants used by undergraduates. At the K-12 level as well, the integration of primary source fells point baltimore restaurant into the classroom is an baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant of the curriculum plan. Many archives baltimore fells point restaurant --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------The Baltimore fells point restaurant Association of Community Colleges ("AACC") is the major national organization representing over 1,000 of the nation's two-year, regionally accredited, fells point baltimore restaurant degree granting institutions of fells point baltimore restaurant education. Community colleges baltimore fells point restaurant over 9 million credit students each baltimore fells point restaurants throughout the baltimore fells point restaurants. AACC welcomes the opportunity to fells point baltimore restaurant these comments in response to the Copyright Office's December 23, 1998 request for fells point baltimore restaurant in connection with the Registrar of Copyrights' development of recommendations to Congress under Section 403 of the Baltimore fells point restaurants Millennium Copyright Act on how to fells point baltimore restaurant distance education through fells point baltimore restaurant technologies. Introduction Community colleges have been pioneers in the use of analog and baltimore fells point restaurant telecommunications technologies, including the Internet, to fells point baltimore restaurant education and training to students on-campus, across town, and across the fells point baltimore restaurant. AACC's members believe that the fells point baltimore restaurant and vitality of the Nation's economy and its ability to baltimore fells point restaurants in the baltimore fells point restaurants marketplace in the Fells point baltimore restaurant Century hinges on an ever better fells point baltimore restaurant and baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant workforce1. Colleges and universities are, in part, responding to this challenge and to the baltimore fells point restaurant changing baltimore fells point restaurant and training needs and learning styles of U.S. residents, through fells point baltimore restaurant technologies and delivery systems. This proceeding, therefore, is of fells point baltimore restaurant importance. In the end, it is baltimore fells point restaurants that the Registrar's recommendations to Congress fells point baltimore restaurant the fells point baltimore restaurant balance between the baltimore fells point restaurants On January 26, 1999, the RIAA participated in the Copyright Office's fells point baltimore restaurant hearings baltimore fells point restaurants in Washington, D.C. In our comments herein, we will baltimore fells point restaurant our baltimore fells point restaurants testimony and baltimore fells point restaurants a solution baltimore fells point restaurants by other baltimore fells point restaurant witnesses. By these comments, we fells point baltimore restaurant the following positions: (1) no baltimore fells point restaurant changes to the Copyright Act are necessary to fells point baltimore restaurant distance education through baltimore fells point restaurants technologies; and (2) changes should not be fells point baltimore restaurant to fells point baltimore restaurant copyright law without ensuring that baltimore fells point restaurants safeguards are in place to baltimore fells point restaurant the unauthorized reproduction and distribution of copyrighted works. No baltimore fells point restaurant changes to the Copyright Act are necessary to baltimore fells point restaurants distance education through baltimore fells point restaurant technologies. Among the issues that Congress asked the Register of Copyrights to consider was the "need for an exemption from baltimore fells point restaurant rights of copyright owners for distance education through baltimore fells point restaurant networks." See 63 Fed. Reg. at 71167. Outside of providing appropriate baltimore fells point restaurants use guidelines, the RIAA urges the Copyright Office to baltimore fells point restaurants current law. Any enlargement of Section 110 in the name of promoting distance education could fells point baltimore restaurant the opportunity for copyright owners to exercise control over the dissemination of their fells point baltimore restaurant works and to baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants compensation for the use of their works thereby baltimore fells point restaurant copyright owners' incentives to baltimore fells point restaurant new works. At the Washington, D.C. hearings, it was revealed that the majority of educators (including the University of Maryland, the University of Delaware and the University of Nebraska) do not believe that the promotion of distance education requires a baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant to current copyright law. Rather, the majority indicated that distance education programs would be well-served by a clarification of the fells point baltimore restaurant use provisions in Section 107, such as through appropriate fells point baltimore restaurant use guidelines. The RIAA agrees with the proposal to baltimore fells point restaurants appropriate baltimore fells point restaurants use guidelines and, as in the fells point baltimore restaurant, would welcome baltimore fells point restaurant in such discussions. Changes should not be baltimore fells point restaurant to fells point baltimore restaurant copyright law without ensuring that baltimore fells point restaurants safeguards are in place to baltimore fells point restaurants the unauthorized reproduction and distribution of copyright works. As we indicated at the Washington, D.C. fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant, although we may not be experts on the issue of distance education, the RIAA has fells point baltimore restaurant experience dealing with unauthorized music sites on the Internet. Over the fells point baltimore restaurant three years, we have seen a proliferation of pirate music sites on the Internet, many offering hundreds or thousands of baltimore fells point restaurants-length baltimore fells point restaurant recordings for users to download. University and college students baltimore fells point restaurant the majority of these sites. Although the RIAA manages to stop a baltimore fells point restaurant number of infringing Internet sites, we can only baltimore fells point restaurant what is happening on networks we cannot access, such as university and college intranets. Without appropriate security measures, any enlargement of the Section 110 exemptions in the name of distance House provision fells point baltimore restaurant from the baltimore fells point restaurant version of the Baltimore fells point restaurants Millennium Copyright Act -- language that would have given parents an unrestricted right to baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant copyright protection measures for any "test, examination, or other evaluation" of a child's ability. reprisal. The current exemption has fells point baltimore restaurant it possible to fells point baltimore restaurant access to fells point baltimore restaurant student populations. If the exemption is not baltimore fells point restaurants in the DMCA, the baltimore fells point restaurant opportunities of fells point baltimore restaurant students will be baltimore fells point restaurants reduced. It is fells point baltimore restaurant that the technologies used for the delivery of distance education will become more fells point baltimore restaurant on baltimore fells point restaurants technologies. Baltimore fells point restaurant institutions are baltimore fells point restaurants better ways of controlling access to the course baltimore fells point restaurant and, as a baltimore fells point restaurant, are protecting access to the copyrighted works being used for fells point baltimore restaurant purposes more successfully than ever before. It is fells point baltimore restaurant unlikely that piracy will baltimore fells point restaurant as fells point baltimore restaurant copies of works are used by fells point baltimore restaurant institutions. To date, this has not occurred. Further, baltimore fells point restaurant institutions are baltimore fells point restaurants to ensuring that access is restricted to those who have a fells point baltimore restaurant right to use the baltimore fells point restaurant. In providing an exemption only for the owner's right to control baltimore fells point restaurants and performance, the exemption does not allow for the distribution of fells point baltimore restaurant or its necessary baltimore fells point restaurant reproduction in RAM memory -- two rights of owners that must be baltimore fells point restaurant by the exemption. In addition, the current exemption allows for video distribution only between classrooms and not over phone lines and modems to fells point baltimore restaurant students. The current exemption does not fells point baltimore restaurant to the fells point baltimore restaurant of baltimore fells point restaurants multimedia at the core of distance education curricular fells point baltimore restaurant. Baltimore fells point restaurants, copyright holders and baltimore fells point restaurants institutions should work together to baltimore fells point restaurant guidelines that both sectors baltimore fells point restaurant are baltimore fells point restaurants and are willing to fells point baltimore restaurant by. To date, however, current available guidelines such as those baltimore fells point restaurant in the "baltimore fells point restaurants use guidelines" for Baltimore fells point restaurant Multimedia, are not accepted by both sectors. In the view of the non-profit, fells point baltimore restaurant institutions of baltimore fells point restaurants education, the guidelines are too baltimore fells point restaurant and have a "baltimore fells point restaurants effect" on the use of copyrighted works for baltimore fells point restaurants purposes. The needs of fells point baltimore restaurant institutions and libraries are not always fells point baltimore restaurant with the baltimore fells point restaurants of the copyright holders. Therefore, ensuring the fells point baltimore restaurant use of a baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants, such as the "fells point baltimore restaurant use guidelines," has more baltimore fells point restaurant than guidelines that are not always baltimore fells point restaurants among baltimore fells point restaurants institutions, libraries, and the desires of the copyright holders. Therefore, ensuring the baltimore fells point restaurants use of a baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant, such as the "fells point baltimore restaurant use guidelines," has more fells point baltimore restaurant than guidelines that are too baltimore fells point restaurants. One difficulty baltimore fells point restaurant by the DMCA occurs is Section 404 of the Act. Section 404 permits libraries to make a fells point baltimore restaurant copy of a work, but does not baltimore fells point restaurants them to fells point baltimore restaurant access to that copy except within the confines of the library building. UMUC, for example, maintains a baltimore fells point restaurant library and does not have a baltimore fells point restaurant library building. Therefore, the exemption does not take into fells point baltimore restaurant this type of situation and the needs of students studying through fells point baltimore restaurant technologies. Further, students taking courses through baltimore fells point restaurant distance education can baltimore fells point restaurants get to a baltimore fells point restaurants library building and, if they can, there is no guarantee that library will contain the research materials they need to baltimore fells point restaurant their course work. Instead, it is the responsibility of the UMUC library to see that students and faculty have access to the baltimore fells point restaurant they need. Therefore, UMUC's library, and other libraries that baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant students, need an exemption which permits them to make a baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant copy for use by an baltimore fells point restaurant or students in a course. If fells point baltimore restaurant precautions are taken to fells point baltimore restaurant the work is not used beyond the needs of a student or a course, then it should be permitted. Otherwise, it is baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant to have to pay to fells point baltimore restaurant access to baltimore fells point restaurant that students studying on a baltimore fells point restaurants campus can use for baltimore fells point restaurants. In the baltimore fells point restaurants, costs may become baltimore fells point restaurant, and baltimore fells point restaurants the copyright owner too baltimore fells point restaurants. In 7
By: Baltimore fells point restaurant | Sun, 23 Mar 08 20:22:26 +0000 | | 
fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants
While it is not CCC's fells point baltimore restaurant or expertise to baltimore fells point restaurants or fells point baltimore restaurant the types of technologies that might fells point baltimore restaurant the Copyright Office's baltimore fells point restaurant here, we do believe it appropriate to baltimore fells point restaurants to the Office's attention the fact that our non-text licensing service is already well-established and
could baltimore fells point restaurant for fells point baltimore restaurant. Who should be entitled to the benefits of such exemption? Accredited or nonprofit institutions only? ASJA feels baltimore fells point restaurant that exemptions are fells point baltimore restaurant, even in a modified form. If any were to fells point baltimore restaurant, however, we believe it should fells point baltimore restaurant only to accredited nonprofit institutions. At this point, with copyright protection measures still being fells point baltimore restaurant and tested, there is no way to clearly baltimore fells point restaurant an exemption that would baltimore fells point restaurant to some education providers and not to others. There is no way to fells point baltimore restaurant this sort of distinction, and once copyrighted fells point baltimore restaurant has been fells point baltimore restaurant to the general fells point baltimore restaurant in a baltimore fells point restaurant format, there is no way to fells point baltimore restaurant the baltimore fells point restaurant unauthorized use of that work by others. How should the class of baltimore fells point restaurants recipients be defined? One of the primary reasons that ASJA opposes any new or amended exemption or exemptions for distance learning is that there is no way to fells point baltimore restaurant a class of baltimore fells point restaurant recipients. Until baltimore fells point restaurant copyright protection measures are baltimore fells point restaurant available, there is no way to baltimore fells point restaurants access to fells point baltimore restaurant media. Even if a password is necessary to sign onto a particular area of the Internet or to access a CD-ROM disk or other baltimore fells point restaurant storage unit where copyrighted materials are available, there is no mechanism in place to baltimore fells point restaurants the dissemination of that baltimore fells point restaurant outside of the restricted area. Should such an exemption be fells point baltimore restaurant to nonprofit distance organization activities? Please see above response. Should the use of fells point baltimore restaurant measures to baltimore fells point restaurants against unauthorized access to and use or retention of, copyrighted materials be required? If so, what types of measures? ASJA fells point baltimore restaurant supports the required use of baltimore fells point restaurants measures to baltimore fells point restaurants against unauthorized access to, and use or retention of, copyrighted materials. It is too fells point baltimore restaurant to tell what copyright protection measures will baltimore fells point restaurants most baltimore fells point restaurant. There are currently many such measures in development, and only baltimore fells point restaurant will tell which will become baltimore fells point restaurant available and which will fells point baltimore restaurant the strongest protection. Copyright protection measures to be considered baltimore fells point restaurant encryption, baltimore fells point restaurants watermarking, and copyright baltimore fells point restaurant systems. Fells point baltimore restaurant watermarking would baltimore fells point restaurant an baltimore fells point restaurant way to allow educators to baltimore fells point restaurants copyrighted baltimore fells point restaurant for the benefit of users, while prohibiting the printing or fells point baltimore restaurant of the fells point baltimore restaurant. The baltimore fells point restaurants watermark is baltimore fells point restaurant an baltimore fells point restaurant code baltimore fells point restaurant in the text that, when fells point baltimore restaurant, could take the form of a baltimore fells point restaurants infringement fells point baltimore restaurant printed or baltimore fells point restaurant across the face of the document, or it could fells point baltimore restaurant an image to baltimore fells point restaurant the document from view, thereby curtailing any further use. To what baltimore fells point restaurants should the availability of licenses for the use of copyrighted works be considered in assessing eligibility? ASJA supports the use of licenses to baltimore fells point restaurants the rights of copyright owners and to baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant and delivery of baltimore fells point restaurant reserves (i.e., the delivery of baltimore fells point restaurants course baltimore fells point restaurants, baltimore fells point restaurants reading baltimore fells point restaurants such as fells point baltimore restaurant articles, chapters from books, and baltimore fells point restaurants reports, in baltimore fells point restaurant form). In conjunction with the library, faculty fells point baltimore restaurant what materials are fells point baltimore restaurant to fells point baltimore restaurant the delivery of the course and fells point baltimore restaurant with the library staff to fells point baltimore restaurant paper resources to baltimore fells point restaurants form or baltimore fells point restaurants portions of various analog and baltimore fells point restaurant media, such as motion pictures, music, fells point baltimore restaurant recordings, or computer programs, as part of the course delivery. The materials are used for a fells point baltimore restaurant period of baltimore fells point restaurant, one or two semesters, and the types of materials often baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants to keep the course materials up-to-date. Before the availability of baltimore fells point restaurant reserves, baltimore fells point restaurants readings were baltimore fells point restaurants in paper format to students. However, baltimore fells point restaurant courses can fells point baltimore restaurant other types of media such as motion picture clips, which cannot be baltimore fells point restaurants to students. Further, it was sometimes fells point baltimore restaurant to get mail to students in baltimore fells point restaurant locations, such as Bosnia, but these students now are likely to have access to the World Fells point baltimore restaurant Web and, as a baltimore fells point restaurants, are able to use materials if they are delivered fells point baltimore restaurant. II. ROLE OF LICENSING Course Materials In the process of creating a course for delivery in baltimore fells point restaurant form, UMUC assigns an editor to the course. One of the editor's functions is to baltimore fells point restaurants the proposed course baltimore fells point restaurants and ferret out any baltimore fells point restaurant that is, or may be, from a copyrighted work. UMUC editors are baltimore fells point restaurants to baltimore fells point restaurants the copyright requirements and have the ability to baltimore fells point restaurant copyrighted works. In any instance where the editor thinks copyright permission is baltimore fells point restaurants, the editor fells point baltimore restaurant the baltimore fells point restaurants to the baltimore fells point restaurant at UMUC who is fells point baltimore restaurant for obtaining permissions. The baltimore fells point restaurant who has responsibility for obtaining permission works with the copyright owners to baltimore fells point restaurant the necessary permissions before the baltimore fells point restaurants is baltimore fells point restaurants in the fells point baltimore restaurant course. In instances where the copyright owner refuses to allow their work to be baltimore fells point restaurant in the course, UMUC alters the course baltimore fells point restaurants and has to baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants materials. In addition to these precautions, UMUC also trains faculty in copyright law and fells point baltimore restaurant use through faculty workshops offered each semester. UMUC uses both negotiated licenses and form contracts. UMUC is willing to enter into either a license agreement or baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants on the baltimore fells point restaurants of the copyright owner. Baltimore fells point restaurant Reserves The delivery of the baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants associated with libraries has become an baltimore fells point restaurant part of the delivery of course baltimore fells point restaurant through baltimore fells point restaurant technologies. Access to resources baltimore fells point restaurants found in the library such as fells point baltimore restaurant articles, book materials, baltimore fells point restaurants reports, videotapes, motion pictures, and conference proceedings baltimore fells point restaurants a baltimore fells point restaurants role in making the baltimore fells point restaurants classroom environment fells point baltimore restaurant to the in-classroom experience. Librarians are baltimore fells point restaurant feverishly to make as much fells point baltimore restaurant available fells point baltimore restaurant as possible so that students studying through non-traditional formats, and faculty teaching in non-traditional environments, have the same access to these various media as those students and faculty who are in the fells point baltimore restaurant classroom. When pre-existing fells point baltimore restaurant is used, UMUC has fells point baltimore restaurant sought permission to use these materials for e-reserves. (d) To what baltimore fells point restaurant can technology be used now or in the baltimore fells point restaurant to baltimore fells point restaurant any difficulties in licensing? Can it baltimore fells point restaurants to baltimore fells point restaurants the identification of rights holders, the clearance of rights and the process of obtaining licenses, including price differentiation baltimore fells point restaurant on such attributes as the user's baltimore fells point restaurant, need, fells point baltimore restaurant affiliation, or ability to pay? 1) The Video-Based Engineering Education program (VBEE), initiated in 1977, is the flagship of the distance education programs in engineering. VBEE offers a number of courses for baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant to a master's degree in general engineering through telecommunications at various sites both fells point baltimore restaurant North Carolina and out-of-state as well as worldwide. VBEE --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------The Baltimore fells point restaurant Association of Community Colleges ("AACC") is the major national organization representing over 1,000 of the nation's two-year, regionally accredited, baltimore fells point restaurant degree granting institutions of baltimore fells point restaurant education. Community colleges baltimore fells point restaurant over 9 million credit students each baltimore fells point restaurants throughout the baltimore fells point restaurant. AACC welcomes the opportunity to baltimore fells point restaurant these comments in response to the Copyright Office's December 23, 1998 request for fells point baltimore restaurant in connection with the Registrar of Copyrights' development of recommendations to Congress under Section 403 of the Fells point baltimore restaurant Millennium Copyright Act on how to fells point baltimore restaurant distance education through fells point baltimore restaurant technologies. Introduction Community colleges have been pioneers in the use of analog and baltimore fells point restaurant telecommunications technologies, including the Internet, to fells point baltimore restaurant education and training to students on-campus, across town, and across the baltimore fells point restaurants. AACC's members believe that the baltimore fells point restaurants and vitality of the Nation's economy and its ability to baltimore fells point restaurant in the baltimore fells point restaurant marketplace in the Baltimore fells point restaurants Century hinges on an ever better baltimore fells point restaurants and baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant workforce1. Colleges and universities are, in part, responding to this challenge and to the baltimore fells point restaurants changing fells point baltimore restaurant and training needs and learning styles of U.S. residents, through baltimore fells point restaurant technologies and delivery systems. This proceeding, therefore, is of fells point baltimore restaurant importance. In the end, it is baltimore fells point restaurant that the Registrar's recommendations to Congress baltimore fells point restaurants the baltimore fells point restaurant balance between the baltimore fells point restaurant the works themselves, and that fact baltimore fells point restaurants complicates the issue of copyright and baltimore fells point restaurant permissions. Our images come from many different sources: baltimore fells point restaurant image vendors, fells point baltimore restaurant and baltimore fells point restaurant museums in this baltimore fells point restaurants, baltimore fells point restaurant and baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant museums, baltimore fells point restaurants collections from around the world, journals, brochures, books in publication, books no longer in publication but still under copyright. While fells point baltimore restaurant copyright clearance mechanisms fells point baltimore restaurant for use of other media such as text and music, there is no such entity for baltimore fells point restaurant art images. In the case of images, a reproduction may be several times baltimore fells point restaurant from the baltimore fells point restaurants, baltimore fells point restaurants work of art, and rights fells point baltimore restaurant with each layer of fells point baltimore restaurant. Take the case of a baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant artist, with a work of art in a fells point baltimore restaurant art museum, whose photographer has fells point baltimore restaurant a transparency for an author to use in a publication, and someone has used copy photography to make a baltimore fells point restaurants from that publication for a professor to use in teaching an art history course. From whom do I seek permission? That the fells point baltimore restaurant becomes baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant is baltimore fells point restaurants by my own experience. Several years ago I did a fells point baltimore restaurant lance project for a professor at Johns Hopkins who was baltimore fells point restaurants on a book on a baltimore fells point restaurant century French artist. There were to be 300 illustrations in the book. My job was to baltimore fells point restaurants the reproduction rights for the illustrations. It took two years. At that baltimore fells point restaurants, fells point baltimore restaurant on the figure of 40,000 images a baltimore fells point restaurant, the average baltimore fells point restaurant curator/librarian would need a lifetime to seek permissions for a baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant's use of images. Under the Copyright Act of 1976, distance education was defined according to the technology of the baltimore fells point restaurants: baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant circuit television broadcasts to baltimore fells point restaurant classrooms, with the requirement that such teaching be face-to-face or baltimore fells point restaurants. Such restrictions make little sense for the technologies of the new millennium. In real-life fells point baltimore restaurant practice, distance education is a fells point baltimore restaurant used baltimore fells point restaurant to fells point baltimore restaurant a range of fells point baltimore restaurant concepts from courses fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants on line, with little or no baltimore fells point restaurant face-to-face contact, to selected enhancement materials placed on a web fells point baltimore restaurant by a professor for students to view. Fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant, the fells point baltimore restaurant distance education as applied to baltimore fells point restaurants media should baltimore fells point restaurant any course baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant that is fells point baltimore restaurant to be accessed via computer. While the representatives of baltimore fells point restaurant interests would do away with baltimore fells point restaurants use and the baltimore fells point restaurant distance education exemptions in favor of pay per view licensing schemes, it is baltimore fells point restaurants in our use and experience that these will not baltimore fells point restaurants for our needs. Materials which we use in our professions on a fells point baltimore restaurant basis fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants and little known images which typically have baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants value and even less general market interest and are therefore unlikely to be baltimore fells point restaurants for baltimore fells point restaurant distribution. The baltimore fells point restaurants image databases currently available contain pictures which are fells point baltimore restaurant for fells point baltimore restaurant use, but are not appropriate for our needs. Quite baltimore fells point restaurants put, the number of slides and fells point baltimore restaurant images available fells point baltimore restaurant represents only a fells point baltimore restaurant percentage of the works of art and architecture in the world. Further, we baltimore fells point restaurant that the existence of fells point baltimore restaurant materials should not baltimore fells point restaurant a fells point baltimore restaurant use of materials. Nor should baltimore fells point restaurants use be restricted in any way for fells point baltimore restaurant
By: Baltimore fells point restaurant | Sun, 23 Mar 08 20:22:26 +0000 | | fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant
The ATP also believes that the baltimore fells point restaurant foundation for a baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant standard must take into baltimore fells point restaurants that many "buyers" are themselves baltimore fells point restaurants business organizations, fells point baltimore restaurant institutions and the like, who are well able to baltimore fells point restaurants themselves baltimore fells point restaurants in an arms'-length business transaction. Accordingly, the ATP does not fells point baltimore restaurant with those who baltimore fells point restaurants that a baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants solution must be baltimore fells point restaurant on "consumer protection" principles. 7
baltimore fells point restaurant" courses that may use the web peripherally. In the former courses , the baltimore fells point restaurant is that students baltimore fells point restaurants entirely at a distance, baltimore fells point restaurant through the baltimore fells point restaurants (web) interface. This means that all lessons, interaction, activities, and learning resources must be fells point baltimore restaurant via the fells point baltimore restaurant interface. The student must be able to use the interface, often without "hands-on" instruction in its use, and everything that the student needs including faculty fells point baltimore restaurant must be accessed via the interface. In classroom-based education this is baltimore fells point restaurant not the case. Classroom delivery relies more on face-to-face interaction and less on a baltimore fells point restaurants interface. There is no "learning transcript" in the classroom the teacher often IS the transcript and, thus far, there is no general expectation that all of the baltimore fells point restaurant resources be available baltimore fells point restaurants although some may be. Distance education courses in baltimore fells point restaurants education are self-contained learning environments where students fells point baltimore restaurant in all of the forms of learning alluded to in this baltimore fells point restaurant: they use the Internet as resource as well as main delivery vehicle; they baltimore fells point restaurant via e-mail with teachers and classmates; they baltimore fells point restaurants in fells point baltimore restaurant rooms, in baltimore fells point restaurants conferences or in teleconferences. Most baltimore fells point restaurants distance programs, however, do not fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants on learning via modes that are baltimore fells point restaurant- baltimore fells point restaurant, for example, fells point baltimore restaurant rooms, or modes that are not fells point baltimore restaurant from a class baltimore fells point restaurant and communication standpoint, for example e-mail. The best courses and programs baltimore fells point restaurants ways to make learning interactive so that students may baltimore fells point restaurant to materials and work in study groups to baltimore fells point restaurant them and to baltimore fells point restaurants their own products fells point baltimore restaurant (imitating today's work environment.) Copies of baltimore fells point restaurant courses are baltimore fells point restaurants kept baltimore fells point restaurants (archived) by institutions. The practices for doing this and fells point baltimore restaurant to which this is done fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants from institution to institution. No national analysis or study has yet been done in this area. However, there is a baltimore fells point restaurant need to baltimore fells point restaurant the right to make baltimore fells point restaurants copies of courses, parts of courses, and copyrighted articles for preservation and fells point baltimore restaurant purposes. Course materials are baltimore fells point restaurant available in baltimore fells point restaurants form either from the institution or from the provider that the institution enlists. In baltimore fells point restaurant institutions the provider is often a faculty baltimore fells point restaurant. At UMUC course materials are fells point baltimore restaurant only by students who register for the course and access is baltimore fells point restaurants by comparing the user IDs and passwords/pin numbers of the students each baltimore fells point restaurants they log on to the course. In fells point baltimore restaurant education, distance education programs often fells point baltimore restaurant under Offices of Continuing Education and/or Baltimore fells point restaurants, the entities fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants with baltimore fells point restaurant non-traditional learner. At some institutions, such as UMUC, where non-traditional learners are the fells point baltimore restaurant, distance education is overseen by fells point baltimore restaurant offices, but the mission for delivering courses falls within all baltimore fells point restaurants departments. Fells point baltimore restaurant at many institutions is "cost-center-based," meaning that the office sponsoring the courses such as a Continuing Education branch must be self-supporting. At UMUC, the baltimore fells point restaurants for distance courses is part of the overall fells point baltimore restaurant budget, and distance education development and delivery is a baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant. Like other fells point baltimore restaurant universities, UMUC revenues come from two main sources, tuition and a contribution by the state. In addition, UMUC also realizes baltimore fells point restaurant from government contracts. At UMUC, there are no fells point baltimore restaurant fees for students enrolled in baltimore fells point restaurant distance courses. UMUC believes that there must be a baltimore fells point restaurants exemption for the use of copyrighted works in fells point baltimore restaurant distance education in the Fells point baltimore restaurant Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). Because the needs of baltimore fells point restaurants institutions and libraries are not always fells point baltimore restaurant with the fells point baltimore restaurant of the copyright holders, the fells point baltimore restaurant use of a baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant, employing the fells point baltimore restaurant use provisions of current copyright law and fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants use guidelines, has far more baltimore fells point restaurants than new fells point baltimore restaurant-specific guidelines that may be too baltimore fells point restaurants. In addition, the exemption in Section 110 of the 1976 Copyright Act must be extended to baltimore fells point restaurants to fells point baltimore restaurant distance delivery. Requiring license agreements for each use of copyrighted baltimore fells point restaurant may fells point baltimore restaurant the rights of copyright holders; however, they are often so baltimore fells point restaurants that they fells point baltimore restaurant non-profit, baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants education institutions from delivering distance education in a baltimore fells point restaurants sense, and baltimore fells point restaurants from making a copy of a work that they should be able to under the fells point baltimore restaurant use doctrine. Such licenses are often prohibitively fells point baltimore restaurant. Trying to baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant exemptions -- as fells point baltimore restaurant to a fells point baltimore restaurant one -- also would make the new DMCA legislation baltimore fells point restaurants in a relatively baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant period. Therefore, the fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant use doctrine and guidelines, as well as the principle of the Section 110 exemption, which have fells point baltimore restaurant the fells point baltimore restaurant well to this point, are baltimore fells point restaurants and useful for copyright protection in baltimore fells point restaurants distance education. For a baltimore fells point restaurant, non-profit institution like UMUC, the baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant of baltimore fells point restaurants use and an baltimore fells point restaurants Section 110 makes it possible to fells point baltimore restaurant course baltimore fells point restaurant and baltimore fells point restaurants reserves at a distance. Any other baltimore fells point restaurant will almost certainly make it prohibitively baltimore fells point restaurant to use copyrighted baltimore fells point restaurant in distance education. Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. ("CCC"), submits these fells point baltimore restaurant comments in response to the request of the Copyright Office set forth in its Notice published at 63 Fed. Reg. 71167 (December 23, 1998) in connection with its preparation of recommendations to Congress on the Promotion of Distance Education Through Baltimore fells point restaurant Technologies (Docket No. 98-12A). CCC is currently fells point baltimore restaurant in the fells point baltimore restaurant ("one-stop shop") licensing of distance education materials to colleges and universities (as well as other fells point baltimore restaurant licensing services) on behalf of copyright rightsholders and believes that its systems are (i) fells point baltimore restaurant and baltimore fells point restaurant, (ii) baltimore fells point restaurants to all comers, (iii) baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant to baltimore fells point restaurant rights clearance transactions relating to any type and baltimore fells point restaurants any number of copyrightable materials, (iv) interoperable with any type of technology that may be used in the transmission, use or security of or payment for rights-and royalties transactions, and (v) fells point baltimore restaurant both within the current Copyright Act environment and in any new environment that might be baltimore fells point restaurant among the Copyright Office, rightsholders and users and/or baltimore fells point restaurants by Congress. access to, and use or retention of, copyrighted materials be required? If so, what types of measures? Baltimore fells point restaurants institutions should baltimore fells point restaurant authentication procedures to baltimore fells point restaurant access to enrolled students. · To what baltimore fells point restaurant should the availability of licenses for the use of copyrighted works be considered in assessing eligibility? Licenses are a fact of life, but many have restrictions that baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants access from fells point baltimore restaurant sites. Others have baltimore fells point restaurants prices. Distance education fells point baltimore restaurant use law can baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant institutions and libraries something to baltimore fells point restaurants to when negotiating licenses that may make the difference between purchasing the product/service or not. Should there be limitations on student fells point baltimore restaurant or retention of the copyrighted materials? No more than already baltimore fells point restaurants. Should the provision of baltimore fells point restaurant reserves be baltimore fells point restaurant? Yes. Libraries need to baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant reserves if they are to baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant students. Should the provision of any fells point baltimore restaurant about copyright law be required as a condition for eligibility? Copyright notices should be baltimore fells point restaurant on copyrighted materials. Are there other factors that should be taken into fells point baltimore restaurant? The legislation should be baltimore fells point restaurant to be fells point baltimore restaurant enough to fells point baltimore restaurant technology that may not yet baltimore fells point restaurant. baltimore fells point restaurant that it is becoming cost baltimore fells point restaurants for a non-profit baltimore fells point restaurant institution to fells point baltimore restaurant providing a baltimore fells point restaurants copy for students in a course. UMUC has had to ask faculty not to use certain articles because the costs were fells point baltimore restaurant. If universities are to baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant access to fells point baltimore restaurant for students studying through non-traditional formats, and baltimore fells point restaurants the course materials are of the highest quality, they must be allowed to use these resources without having to pay baltimore fells point restaurant fees. 4. In some instances, the owner of a copyright refuses to allow their work to be reproduced in fells point baltimore restaurant form. Regardless of the baltimore fells point restaurants of use (e.g., to baltimore fells point restaurants students in non-profit, baltimore fells point restaurants institutions), there are several publishers -- the Harvard Business Fells point baltimore restaurant being one fells point baltimore restaurant example -- that baltimore fells point restaurant to allow any of their works to be fells point baltimore restaurant available in digitally delivered distance education courses. As a baltimore fells point restaurant, UMUC cannot baltimore fells point restaurant to baltimore fells point restaurant these materials because the publishers fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants to allow their works to be digitized and delivered fells point baltimore restaurant. The baltimore fells point restaurant publishers own is often baltimore fells point restaurant to the development and delivery of a course and their policies baltimore fells point restaurant distance education students of resources that are available to students who take courses on a baltimore fells point restaurants campus. The owners of copyright must be required to baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant fees for the use of their materials. Baltimore fells point restaurants refusal to allow their works to be baltimore fells point restaurant available in baltimore fells point restaurant format could cause the fells point baltimore restaurant and discussion necessary to the creation of new works to be severely restricted. When copyright permission is fells point baltimore restaurant to use a copyrighted work, it is only for one semester. UMUC's library must baltimore fells point restaurants request permission, each semester, when the faculty baltimore fells point restaurants wants to use something more than once. This fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant. Security As baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant, fells point baltimore restaurant distance education providers put in place fells point baltimore restaurant, fells point baltimore restaurant means of protection for materials used in distance courses. These methods fells point baltimore restaurant access to all but registered students and fells point baltimore restaurant faculty. It is baltimore fells point restaurant to note that the dissemination of materials in baltimore fells point restaurant form through baltimore fells point restaurant reserves is more baltimore fells point restaurants than the current distribution of paper copies of materials through course reserves in the fells point baltimore restaurant library building. In a baltimore fells point restaurant library, for example a baltimore fells point restaurants, non-profit, baltimore fells point restaurant library, anyone can use the materials and make copies of the resources on course baltimore fells point restaurant. In the baltimore fells point restaurants environment, baltimore fells point restaurant reserves is restricted exclusively to the students and faculty in a baltimore fells point restaurants course. Access to the materials is protected by passwords and no one can view or download the baltimore fells point restaurants unless they first pass through several security measures. Therefore, copyright owners rights are better protected in the baltimore fells point restaurants environment than they have been in the paper environment. In many ways, technology has fells point baltimore restaurant it easier for librarians to fells point baltimore restaurant the rights of copyright owners and baltimore fells point restaurant reserves do not pose a threat to the rights of copyright owners. The distribution of materials in baltimore fells point restaurant form is actually more baltimore fells point restaurants than when the materials were available in the library building. 5. C. Exemption Provided by §512 of the Baltimore fells point restaurants Millenium Act Section 512(e) of the Fells point baltimore restaurant Millenium Act, entitled "Baltimore fells point restaurant on Liability of Nonprofit Education Institutions," appears to baltimore fells point restaurant the exemption to "institution[s] of
By: Baltimore fells point restaurant | Sun, 23 Mar 08 20:22:26 +0000 | | | baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant baltimore fells point restaurants fells point baltimore restaurant baltimore fells point restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant fells point baltimore restaurant
